Agentless v agent-based monitoring

Back to news

 

agentless

There are many factors to consider during the product evaluation phase of any IT monitoring solution.  In this blog we aim to help decision makers understand the pros and cons of agent-based and agentless deployments.

 

IT monitoring solutions can be complex products, each offering an array of features and functionality.  To make product comparisons easier, it helps to break down the long list  of such features into broad categories and focus on what’s important to the individual organization.

When considering the implementation phase and the on-going maintenance of monitoring solutions, it’s important to be aware of the pros and cons of agent-based and agentless approaches.  Their impact varies depending on; the delivery resources the organization has available, the current size of the IT estate and estimated future expansion, but in general they can be outlined as follows:

Pros

 

Agent-based
  • Can capture performance when network connectivity to central server is compromised
  • Can offer more granular/detailed monitoring

 

Agentless
  • No remote software to install
  • Generally lower initialcost
  • No “on device” resource overhead
  • WMI and VMware agentless monitoring can complement traditional SNMP monitoring

Cons

 

Agent-based
  • Requires installation and ongoing maintenance of additional software on each device to be monitored
  • Installation may be prohibited by end customer organisations (important for Service Providers)
  • Takes CPU and RAM resources from each device with a running agent installed
Agentless
  • Less granular monitoring and data collection
  • Can be hamstrung by networking configuration or networking issues (firewalls)

More recent posts from the Servicenav team

3/4/18

“Monitoring the virtual layer: the secret sauce of consolidation”

Virtualisation brings great benefits, but it needs care and attention to perform at its best.   How did we get here? Virtualisation technologies initially emerged… Read more

28/3/18

Capacity Planning for ServiceNav

Capacity Planning or Capacity Management is a major challenge for CIOs with a service management responsibility. The goal of Capacity Management is to ensure that… Read more

28/3/18

Hybrid cloud is sooo… yesterday: Multi-Cloud is here!

The Cloud industry literature is awash with “Multi-Cloud”..what is it , and why does it matter?   Hybrid Cloud was always the “go to” term… Read more